Dividends
to the Rescue
By Stephen J. Butler |
Archives |
Are you old enough to remember dividends? Those were annual payments
to stockholders. They were lost or forgotten during the nineties
when shouldered out of the way by a booming stock market. Stock
prices, relative to earnings, were so high that dividends, if
paid at all, were only amounting to about 1% of the stock price.
Historically,
dividends have played a large role in the recovery of seemingly
doomed portfolios. After '73-74, it took the S&P 500 seven-and-a-half
years to return to its pre-crash value from just a capital appreciation
standpoint. However, when adding in reinvested dividends, the
time period was only three-and-a-half years. One current popular
newsletter keeps harping on the fact that the market required
seventeen years to recover from its 1930's decline. This statistic
totally ignores dividends which averaged as much as 10% per year
during some years through the thirties up until the mid fifties.
Now, with large
dividend-paying companies having lost over 30% of their value
in the last two years, dividends offer some immediate gratification
that can dramatically accelerate the recovery of a retirement
portfolio. In a tax-deferred retirement plan, dividends accumulate
without being taxed, so they are much more valuable as a wealth-generating
tool than they would have been in a taxable environment.
Dividends are
paid out as a portion of company earnings, so companies have to
be profitable to support continuing dividend payments. As a general
rule, the dividend amount per share remains constant in dollars
and becomes a different percentage as the share price changes.
It is a major event when a company changes its dividend payout
per share. In some cases, companies will temporarily dip into
capital and pay more in dividends than they had in earnings to
avoid adverse publicity.
As a matter
of principle, many companies simply don't pay dividends. They
operate on the theory that profits should be spent to "grow the
company" and generate returns to stockholders in the form of appreciated
stock values. This philosophy can be valuable to us as we invest
after-tax money, because our annual "earnings" of appreciation
accumulate as tax-deferred, long-term gains. Today, however, the
vast majority of us own the bulk of our stock market investments
in retirement plans where this advantage goes to waste.
Where do we
find high dividend yields? Utility funds, Real Estate Investment
Trusts (REIT's,) the Dogs of the Dow, and screening for individual
stocks that pay high dividends are all places to start.
Utility funds
investing in companies providing power and phones have traditionally
paid relatively high dividends. As a group, they currently pay
dividends averaging about 3%. However, they have had substantial
capital losses over the past two years thanks to the implosion
of their telecommunications holdings. Today, however, with those
40% cumulative losses behind them, these funds offer a steady
stream of dividends and an improved possibility of future gains.
Vanguard's Utility Income Fund is shifting gears and changing
its name to Vanguard Dividend Growth Fund in an effort to focus
on the entire spectrum of dividend-paying companies and industries.
REIT funds invest
in real estate properties and have been paying dividends averaging
7% for the fund sector as a whole. In addition, these funds have
generated substantial capital gains over the past three years
where they had previously been flat for some periods. My only
hesitation with this category is that they could become victims
of their recent success. With new buildings still coming out of
the ground across the country and with an economy that is languishing,
I would be concerned about a reduction in dividends and a drop
in capital values if the past two years have represented what
looks like a "bubble."
The Dogs of
the Dow are the ten stocks of the Dow Jones Average that pay the
highest percentage dividend. Right now, that list includes various
household names paying an average dividend of about 4%.
Finally, a little
research using one of the free screening tools on the Internet
can generate long lists of individual stocks that pay dividends
of well over 10% per year. Some company involving golf properties
is paying 48%. Since there is no free lunch, we can all guess
at the level of risk when companies offer two-digit dividend yields,
but these screening tools are instructive and can be found at
sites like www.multexinvestor.com
and www.moneycentral.msn.com.
Dividends, then,
are important to appreciate. If stock market capital values only
increase over the next ten years by an average of 7% per year,
then dividends will offer a substantial boost to annual returns.
What's more, they will offer at least a smidgen of satisfaction
while we endure what promises to be a choppy market in the years
ahead. And finally, the growing attraction of anything increases
its demand and value. Stocks or mutual funds that offer dividends
may become increasingly popular with further publicity. A self-fulfilling
prophecy should boost the overall values of dividend-producing
assets, so if the concept is of interest, the time to explore
the possibilities is now.
BUYandHOLD does
not recommend any securities. Any securities mentioned above are
being used for illustrative and informational purposes only and
should not be regarded as an offer to sell or as a solicitation
of an offer to buy.
|